Sick Building Syndrome, What Cleaning Can and Cannot Fix

Sick building syndrome is the name for headaches, dry eyes, a stuffy nose, tiredness and trouble concentrating that show up when people spend time in a particular building and ease soon after they leave. Cleaning can fix some of the causes, mainly dust and the fumes from the cleaning itself. But the most common cause by a wide margin is ventilation, and no cleaning crew can fix that.

So the useful question is which kind of problem you have, because that decides who you should be calling, and most offices can tell from five clues they can check this week. Also, one of the most common winter complaints traces to something neither cleaning nor extra fresh air will fix.

What Sick Building Syndrome Actually Is

The EPA’s fact sheet on the subject uses the term for situations where people “experience acute health and comfort effects that appear to be linked to time spent in a building,” with no specific illness or cause anyone can point to. It lists three signs:

  • People complain of symptoms of acute discomfort.
  • The cause of the symptoms isn’t known.
  • Most of them feel better soon after leaving the building.

That last one is the tell. The NHS describes the same pattern. Symptoms get worse the longer you stay and ease after you leave, and other people in the building usually have them too.

It isn’t the same as building related illness, which is a real, diagnosable disease tied to the building, such as Legionnaires’ disease or a lung reaction to mold. The EPA notes that people with building related illness may take a long time to recover after leaving. If someone’s symptoms don’t fade on weekends, or a doctor has diagnosed something, that’s a medical and building engineering matter, not a cleaning one.


Why Ventilation Is Usually the Culprit

When the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) looked back at about 500 indoor air investigations, it sorted the causes like this, as reported in OSHA’s Technical Manual:

Cause NIOSH foundShare of investigations
Inadequate ventilation52 percent
Contamination from inside the building16 percent
Contamination from outside the building10 percent
Microbial contamination5 percent
Contamination from the building materials4 percent
Unknown13 percent

Those investigations are decades old, and buildings have changed since. But the order hasn’t, and OSHA’s manual still tells its own inspectors to start with the ventilation survey because it’s the leading cause.

Part of the story is history. The EPA explains that after the 1973 oil embargo, ventilation standards dropped to about 5 cubic feet per minute of outdoor air per person to save energy, which proved too little for many buildings.

The standard went back up in 1989 to at least 15 per person, and 20 in offices. A building that was set up during those years, or one whose fresh air dampers have been closed down to save on heating, may still be running short.

A cleaning crew can’t open a damper, and that’s the plain limit of what cleaning can do here.


Five Clues That Tell You Which Problem You Have

Most of the work is just noticing when and where people feel bad, and that doesn’t cost anything. Each clue below points at a different cause, and a different person to call.

1. It gets worse in the afternoon and in crowded rooms

Stuffy air that builds through the day, headaches in the big conference room, and drowsiness after lunch point at ventilation.

A cheap carbon dioxide meter tells you a lot here. OSHA’s manual treats 1,000 parts per million as a sign of inadequate ventilation, and ASHRAE says CO2 at normal indoor levels isn’t a direct health risk, so treat the reading as a gauge of how much fresh air the room gets. Call the HVAC contractor or the building engineer.

2. It’s worst right after the cleaning visit

If people feel it first thing in the morning, or notice a chemical or perfume smell when they walk in, the cleaning itself may be the source.

The EPA lists cleaning agents right next to carpet, adhesives and copy machines as indoor sources of volatile organic compounds. OSHA’s manual names air fresheners and carpet cleaning too. This one’s fixable by your cleaning company: fragrance free products, measured dilution instead of free pouring, and enough time for a carpet to dry before people arrive. Scent free cleaning products and policies cover what to ask for.

3. There’s visible dust, and it comes back fast

Dust on desks by midday, gray fluff in the corners and sneezing after the vacuum runs point at dust control. It can come from a vacuum that blows fine dust back into the air, from tracked in grit, or from a recent renovation.

This is squarely a cleaning fix, with damp dusting instead of feather dusters and HEPA filtered vacuums that keep fine dust out of the air.

Renovation dust is its own case: fine dust after an office renovation keeps settling for weeks unless the ducts and filters are dealt with too.

4. It smells musty, or a ceiling tile has a stain

A musty smell, a brown ring on a ceiling tile, or carpet that feels damp near a window points at water and the mold that follows it. The EPA lists wet ceiling tiles, carpet and insulation, along with standing water in ducts and drain pans, as where biological contaminants grow.

Cleaning can wipe a hard surface, but OSHA’s guidance is that moldy ceiling tiles and mildewed carpet get removed and thrown away, and the leak gets repaired. Call the landlord or your facilities person, not the cleaner.

5. It’s only near one spot

Fumes near the loading dock, the parking garage side or a rooftop exhaust point at outdoor air getting pulled in. The EPA notes that vehicle and building exhaust can enter through poorly placed air intakes, windows and other openings. That’s a building and HVAC question.


What a Good Cleaning Program Fixes, and What It Doesn’t

The split between what cleaning fixes and what it can’t is fairly clean.

Cleaning can fix:

  • Surface dust and the fine dust a poor vacuum puts back in the air
  • Fumes and fragrance from the cleaning products themselves
  • Carpet left damp after cleaning, which can smell and grow mildew
  • Tracked in soil at the entrances
  • Spotting and reporting what it sees, such as a stained tile or a wet patch, on the nightly walk

Cleaning can’t fix:

  • Too little fresh air, or air that isn’t reaching the rooms people use
  • Dirty or skipped HVAC filters, which belong to whoever services the system
  • Leaks, wet insulation and mold growing inside the building
  • Fumes coming in from outside
  • Temperature and humidity, which OSHA’s manual puts at 68 to 76 degrees and 20 to 60 percent humidity

That second list is where most of the complaints live. In a Northeastern Pennsylvania winter, for example, the heat runs dry for months, and dry eyes and itchy skin in February can trace to air that’s simply too dry rather than to anything the crew did or didn’t do.

Cleaning does have one advantage over every other trade, because the crew is in every room every night. A crew that’s told to report water stains, musty smells and wet carpet becomes the earliest warning a building has.

That’s one more reason to pick the crew carefully, and the step by step office cleaning hiring guide explains how. If problems in a building do get missed, what it costs when office cleaning slips shows where the money goes.


Who to Call First

Start with when and where people feel it. That’s free, and it’s the same first step OSHA’s inspectors take.

  • If it’s stuffy, worse in the afternoon or in full rooms, call the HVAC contractor or building engineer and ask for an outdoor air check.
  • If it’s worse in the morning, or there’s a chemical or perfume smell, call your cleaning company and ask what products and dilutions it uses.
  • If it’s dusty, ask your cleaner about its vacuum filtration and dusting method.
  • If there’s a musty smell or a stain, call the landlord or facilities manager about a leak.
  • If one person’s symptoms don’t fade away from work, that person should see a doctor.

If you’d like the cleaning side checked, Excellence Janitorial offers free estimates with no commitment, and a walkthrough is a good time to talk about products and dusting. The ventilation side needs the HVAC people.


Frequently Asked Questions

What are the symptoms of sick building syndrome?

The common symptoms are headaches, a blocked or runny nose, dry or sore eyes and throat, dry itchy skin, a cough, tiredness and trouble concentrating. The pattern matters more than any one symptom. They get worse the longer someone stays in the building, ease soon after they leave, and usually affect several people.

What causes sick building syndrome?

The exact cause usually isn’t known, which is part of the definition. In about 500 indoor air investigations by NIOSH, inadequate ventilation was the cause in 52 percent, contamination from inside the building in 16 percent, outdoor contamination in 10 percent and microbial contamination in 5 percent. Cleaning products are one of the indoor sources.

Can cleaning products cause sick building syndrome?

They can contribute. The EPA lists cleaning agents among the indoor sources of volatile organic compounds, alongside carpet, adhesives and copy machines, and OSHA names air fresheners and carpet cleaning. Fragrance free products, correct dilution and letting carpet dry before people arrive cut that source down.

How do you test a building for sick building syndrome?

There’s no single test. Investigators start by asking when and where people feel ill, then check the ventilation, often with carbon dioxide readings, and look for indoor and outdoor pollution sources and water damage. OSHA’s manual treats indoor CO2 above about 1,000 parts per million as a sign of inadequate ventilation.

Is sick building syndrome the same as mold?

No. Mold can be one cause, but sick building syndrome describes symptoms with no clear cause that ease when people leave. When a specific illness is diagnosed and tied to the building, such as a reaction to mold, it’s called building related illness, and the fix is removing the moldy material and repairing the leak.

Ready for a Cleaner Space?

We work with businesses across Scranton, Wilkes-Barre, Kingston, and all of northeastern PA. Tell us about your space and we’ll get back to you with a no-obligation quote.